The ranking list of law reviews at http://law.wlu.edu/library/mostcited/ has been updated. The default ranking has been changed to that of "impact factor" (citations to a journal divided by the number of articles the journal published) - although it's easy to criticize the methodology and philosophy of impact factors I'm inclined to think that it gives a fairer ranking of journals than looking at total citations.
Top 10 journals based on impact factor are:
1 Yale Law Journal 12.1
2 Columbia Law Review 11.5
3 Supreme Court Review 11.4
4 New York University Law Review 11.3
5 Cornell Law Review 11.2
5 Stanford Law Review 11.2
7 Virginia Law Review 10.9
8 Harvard Law Review 10.3
9 California Law Review 9.6
10 Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review 9.5